As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- Lightest ListedOutdoor Research Alpine Merino 150 GloveCheck price on Amazon
- Waterproof 3-in-1Outdoor Research Arete Modular GORE-TEX GloveCheck price on Amazon
- Insulated Winter GloveBlack Diamond Guide GlovesCheck price on Amazon
The Short Answer: Based on our reading of the specs, for high-effort hikes start with Outdoor Research’s Alpine Merino 150, listed at 1.2 oz (34 g). For cold, wet days look at the Arete Modular glove or mitt, which list a GORE-TEX waterproof insert, 100G insulation and a removable fleece liner. For very cold days, Black Diamond lists the Guide Gloves with 170 g of PrimaLoft Gold CrossCore insulation. Black Diamond’s Midweight Softshell is a light, active-day glove.
We compared the makers’ own product pages and one CDC page on frostbite; we did not test these gloves. Our affiliate disclosure explains how links work.
| Glove | Listed weight | Waterproof insert | Insulation | Touchscreen | Check price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Outdoor Research Alpine Merino 150 | 34 g (1.2 oz) | None listed | None listed | Yes | Check price on Amazon |
| Outdoor Research Arete Modular glove | 265 g (9.35 oz) | GORE-TEX | EnduraLoft 100G | Yes, on liner | Check price on Amazon |
| Outdoor Research Arete Modular mitt | 271 g (9.55 oz) | GORE-TEX | EnduraLoft 100G | Yes, on liner | Check price on Amazon |
| Black Diamond Guide Gloves | 299 to 356 g by size | GORE-TEX | PrimaLoft Gold CrossCore 170 g | Not listed | Check price on Amazon |
| Black Diamond Midweight Softshell | 92 g | None listed | None listed | Yes | Check price on Amazon |

Reading the figures
Weight

The listed weights fall into two groups. Outdoor Research lists the Alpine Merino 150 at 34 g, and Black Diamond lists the Midweight Softshell at 92 g. The insulated, waterproof gloves are much heavier: 265 g for the Arete Modular glove, 271 g for the mitt, and 299 to 356 g for the Guide Gloves depending on size. Black Diamond lists a range by size, so treat the gaps as a rough guide.


Waterproofing and insulation
Three of the five list a GORE-TEX waterproof insert: the two Arete Modular gloves and the Black Diamond Guide Gloves. Outdoor Research and Black Diamond list no waterproofing for the Alpine Merino 150 or the Midweight Softshell.
Insulation is listed in different ways. The Arete Modular glove and mitt list EnduraLoft 100G, and the Guide Gloves list 170 g PrimaLoft Gold CrossCore on the back of the hand with a Y-warm palm. The Alpine Merino 150 and the Midweight Softshell list no insulation. Do not compare those numbers across brands as if they were the same measure.

Sizing and fit
Each maker uses its own sizing method. On the Alpine Merino 150 page, Outdoor Research says to measure around a flat hand at the knuckles without the thumb, then measure hand length from the base of the palm to the end of the middle finger, and use the larger number. On the Guide Gloves page, Black Diamond says to measure from the crease at the base of the wrist, palm side, to the tip of the middle finger. Check the size chart on each glove’s own page before you order.

Our picks
Each box below covers one glove or mitt, with specs taken from the maker’s page. The trade-offs are our reading of those specs, not test results.
A 1.2 oz (34 g) stretch-knit glove of merino, polyester and elastane that Outdoor Research describes as a baselayer for the hands. Who it's for: Someone who wants light warmth on high-effort days, or a liner under a heavier glove. A waterproof, windproof glove with a removable 300-weight fleece liner glove, listed at 9.35 oz (265 g). Who it's for: Someone who wants one glove system that adjusts for changing cold. The same construction as the Arete glove in a mitt shape, listed at 9.55 oz (271 g). Who it's for: Someone who puts warmth ahead of finger dexterity. A goatskin and stretch-fabric shell with 170 g PrimaLoft Gold CrossCore insulation, a GORE-TEX insert and a removable wool liner. Who it's for: Someone who needs dexterity, durability and insulation on very cold days. A 92 g four-way stretch softshell glove with a goat skin palm and a digital thumb and index finger. Who it's for: Someone who wants a stretchy, breathable glove for active, chilly days.
Outdoor Research Alpine Merino 150 Glove
Strengths
Drawbacks

Outdoor Research Arete Modular GORE-TEX Glove
Strengths
Drawbacks

Outdoor Research Arete Modular GORE-TEX Mitt
Strengths
Drawbacks

Black Diamond Guide Gloves
Strengths
Drawbacks

Black Diamond Midweight Softshell Gloves
Strengths
Drawbacks
What the makers do not state

How to choose
- Start with the job. Outdoor Research says the Alpine Merino 150 suits high-output activity alone, or goes under heavier gloves in severe conditions.
- Pick wet or dry. The Arete gloves and mitt and the Guide Gloves each list a GORE-TEX insert; the Alpine Merino 150 and Midweight Softshell list no waterproofing.
- Decide on liners. The Arete glove and mitt and the Guide Gloves each list a removable liner.
- Measure your hand. Use each maker’s own method, because they differ.

The CDC says frostbite most often affects the nose, ears, cheeks, chin, fingers and toes. Signs include white or grayish-yellow skin, unusually firm or waxy skin and numbness. If you suspect it, remove wet clothing, seek medical attention as soon as possible, and warm the area in warm, not hot, water or with body heat. The CDC says not to rub the skin or use a heating pad, heat lamp or stove, because numb skin burns easily.
Bottom Line
Bottom Line
Choose the Alpine Merino 150 for light warmth or as a liner, the Arete Modular glove or mitt for a waterproof system with a fleece liner, the Guide Gloves for a heavily insulated glove on very cold days and the Midweight Softshell for active chilly days. Compare weights only where the makers list them.
For more ideas, see our hiking guides, or browse all of our buying guides.
Frequently asked questions
Which of these gloves list a waterproof insert?
The Arete Modular glove and mitt, and the Black Diamond Guide Gloves list a GORE-TEX insert.
Which is the lightest?
Outdoor Research lists the Alpine Merino 150 at 1.2 oz (34 g). Black Diamond lists the Midweight Softshell at 92 g.
Which list touchscreen use?
The Alpine Merino 150 and the Midweight Softshell list it. The Arete glove and mitt list it on the removable liner.
How do I size these gloves?
Check the size chart on each glove's own page. For example, Outdoor Research's Alpine Merino 150 page measures around the flat hand at the knuckles and hand length and uses the larger, and Black Diamond's Guide Gloves page measures from the wrist crease to the middle fingertip.