As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- Heaviest Listed FabricMinus33 Expedition Wool BottomCheck price on Amazon
- Synthetic OptionPatagonia Capilene Thermal Weight BottomsCheck price on Amazon
- Built for Winter HikingIcebreaker Merino 260 Tech Thermal LeggingsCheck price on Amazon
The Short Answer: Based on our reading of the specs, for cold, still camp evenings, start with Minus33, which lists a 400 g/m2 heavyweight merino interlock. For active days, look at Icebreaker (260 gsm) or Smartwool (250 g/m2), both midweight merino. If you want a synthetic option, Patagonia lists a 92% recycled polyester and 8% elastane jersey. Smartwool is 100% merino and Icebreaker is 100% merino excluding the waistband.
This guide compares bottoms (long underwear), not tops. All four listings are the men’s versions. We used the makers’ product pages and a short excerpt from one university extension column; we did not test these products. Our affiliate disclosure explains how links work.
What a base layer is for

University of Minnesota Extension advises sweat-wicking material for socks, underwear and base layers when you work in the cold. It names synthetic, wool, silk and bamboo fibers. That column is a general cold-work source, not a camping guide, so we use it only for the basic job of a base layer.
A winter camp mixes two jobs. You move around while you set up, then you sit still while it cools off. That is why fabric weight and fiber matter when you choose long underwear for the legs.
Merino or synthetic

Three of these bottoms are merino. Smartwool says its Classic Thermal fabric combines the moisture management, temperature regulation and odor resistance of merino wool with an interlock knit for comfort. The Smartwool and Minus33 bottoms are listed as 100% merino. Icebreaker lists 100% merino excluding the waistband.
Patagonia takes the other route. It lists a Polartec Power Grid jersey of 92% recycled polyester and 8% elastane, with HeiQ Mint odor control and an anti-pilling finish. Patagonia describes the bottoms as breathable microfleece baselayers with grid interiors.

Reading the fabric weights

Smartwool and Minus33 list grams per square meter (g/m2), and Icebreaker’s gsm is the same unit. On that shared basis, Minus33’s 400 is the heaviest and Smartwool’s 250 is the lightest of the three. Patagonia lists its fabric as 4.5 oz (153 g), and lists the garment weight as 142 g (5 oz). We keep those two numbers apart from the chart.
On the shared g/m2 basis, Minus33 lists 400, Icebreaker 260 and Smartwool 250.
The Minus33 figures come from its Katmai Men’s Expedition Wool Bottom page. It lists a 400 g/m2 heavyweight interlock knit with 18.5 micron fibers, in 100% merino wool sourced in Australia. Icebreaker calls its 260 gsm leggings midweight, and Smartwool lists its 250 g/m2 bottom as midweight.
Our picks

Each box below covers one pair of bottoms, with the specs taken from the maker’s own page. They run from the heaviest fabric to the synthetic option, then the two midweight merino bottoms. The trade-offs in each box are our reading of those specs, not test results.
A 100% merino, 400 g/m2 heavyweight interlock knit with 18.5 micron fibers, listed on Minus33's Katmai men's page. Who it's for: Someone who expects to be still and cold, not working hard. A Polartec Power Grid jersey of 92% recycled polyester and 8% elastane. Who it's for: Someone who wants a synthetic base layer with built-in odor control. A 260 gsm merino legging that Icebreaker calls midweight, for skiing, winter hiking or cold-weather layering. Who it's for: Someone who wants a midweight merino layer for active days. A 100% merino, 250 g/m2 midweight interlock knit. Who it's for: Someone who wants a merino layer with a merino-lined waistband.
Minus33 Expedition Wool Bottom
Strengths
Drawbacks

Patagonia Capilene Thermal Weight Bottoms
Strengths
Drawbacks

Icebreaker Merino 260 Tech Thermal Leggings
Strengths
Drawbacks

Smartwool Classic Thermal 250 Bottom
Strengths
Drawbacks
Quick comparison
The table below sets the four bottoms side by side on the fiber, fabric, fit and care that each maker lists.

| Base layer | Fiber | Listed fabric | Fit | Listed care |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minus33 Expedition | 100% merino | 400 g/m2 | Regular | Machine wash and dry |
| Patagonia Capilene Thermal | 92% recycled polyester, 8% elastane | 4.5 oz (153 g) | Fitted | Wash warm, tumble dry low |
| Icebreaker Merino 260 Tech | 100% merino, excluding waistband | 260 gsm | Slim | Wash cold, line dry |
| Smartwool Classic Thermal 250 | 100% merino | 250 g/m2 | Slim | Wash warm, tumble dry low |
How to choose

- Match the weight to your day. For long, still evenings, our reading of the specs points to Minus33’s 400 g/m2. For active days, Icebreaker’s 260 gsm or Smartwool’s 250 g/m2 are the midweight choices.
- Pick the fiber. Merino for Smartwool, Icebreaker and Minus33; recycled polyester and elastane for Patagonia.
- Check the fit. Smartwool and Icebreaker list a slim fit, Patagonia lists Fitted, and Minus33 lists Regular with a little room to breathe.
- Check the details. Icebreaker and Smartwool both list a functioning fly and flatlock seams. Smartwool adds a merino-lined elastic waistband, and Icebreaker adds a gusset for mobility.

Care and washing

Care labels differ by maker. Smartwool says machine wash warm on a gentle cycle, wash with like colors, do not bleach, tumble dry low, cool iron as needed, do not dry clean. Patagonia says machine wash warm, do not bleach, tumble dry low, cool iron, no fabric softeners.
Icebreaker says machine wash cold on a gentle cycle, wash with like colors, no softeners, no bleach, do not tumble dry, line dry in the shade, cool iron. Minus33 lists machine wash and dry, which it calls Total Easy Care. Read your garment’s own label before you wash it.
Bottom Line

Bottom Line
Choose Minus33 for cold, still camp evenings, Icebreaker or Smartwool midweight merino for active days, and Patagonia if you want a synthetic jersey. Compare the weights only on the shared g/m2 basis, and check the fit that each maker lists.
For more ideas, see our camping and camping and backpacking guides, or browse all of our buying guides.
Frequently asked questions

What fabric weight do these base layers list?
Minus33 lists 400 g/m2, Icebreaker 260 gsm and Smartwool 250 g/m2. Patagonia lists a 4.5-oz (153-g) fabric and a 142-g (5-oz) garment.
Which are merino and which are synthetic?
Smartwool and Minus33 list 100% merino wool. Icebreaker lists 100% merino wool, excluding the waistband. Patagonia lists 92% recycled polyester and 8% elastane.
Which fits are listed?
Smartwool and Icebreaker list a slim fit, Patagonia lists Fitted and Minus33 lists Regular.
What does a base layer need to do in the cold?
University of Minnesota Extension advises sweat-wicking material such as synthetic, wool, silk or bamboo fibers for base layers.